Discussion about this post

User's avatar
AhJayEff's avatar

I was introduced to this Substack by Sean Thomas, who references it in his article "Rue Britannia: America's Obsession With British Decline" for the UK current affairs magazine The Spectator.

You write that there seems to be "no vision" to the future of the country. This is actually wrong - there is a vision, but it is one that is hostile to the UK.

The UK is led by a political class that hates its own country. I don't mean this as your usual party-political rabble-rousing, but it is literally, objectively true.

George Orwell wrote about how English socialism was peculiar in its allergy to patriotism, that a right-on sort would rather be caught stealing from the donation box for poor relief than standing for the national anthem, and little has changed in the intervening century. Gus O'Donnell, the Cabinet Secretary (head of the British Civil Service) 2005-11, publicly stated "I think it's my job to maximise global welfare not national welfare" - the man who effectively runs the country, actively seeking to impoverish it. I also recommend that you look up the concept of "managed decline" - it was the educated, sophisticated, metropolitan opinion of the post-war consensus that Britain's time in the sun had passed and it was the duty of the Sensible, Mature, Correct people of the Establishment to make an orderly smooth transition and gently guide us down the path of dismantling Britain as a sovereign entity to be subsumed into a European superstate, like a hospice nurse encouraging the dying man to walk into the light, gradually enough that the lower orders didn't notice their country was being stolen from them and cause an unseemly amount of inefficient disruption to prolong the process. British politicians don't really have any interest in national government and only see it as a tedious ritual until they can qualify for a job-for-life on an EU or international legal committee somewhere. It's only gotten worse with the rise of wokery and we have a new generation of self-loathing activists who are consumed by post-colonial guilt and believe that Britain must be punished for the collective guilt of the inherited sins of empire. On the other side of the social scale, there is a pompous, arch contempt for "showy" patriotism - waving a flag is so terribly declassé, darling.

Our political class is a toxic mix of deranged "Imagine" utopianists, bean-counting accountants who only see immigration as Make Big Number Go Up More and have zero intelligence about its social costs, and bureaucratic jobsworths who only care about their pension. None of them prioritise the nation.

Expand full comment
Robert Jessel's avatar

From an Englishman, this is insightful and almost entirely correct essay. I would take issue with Conservative leader being called a "black Nigerian" as if that's the most important thing about her. In fact, she's a great example of how immigration *should* work (not that this fact makes her the best leader of the Tories, or the country).

But aside from a couple of small things, the diagnosis is terrifyingly accurate, and civil war of some sort is inevitable. I imagine it'll start with citizens coalescing into gangs, targeting opponents' businesses, cultural and religious centres; street violence, squalid murders, that whole Northern Ireland 1969-1997 vibe, but even more insanely complicated.

Expand full comment
42 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?